πΊοΈ The outlet map
Every outlet we read on enough of our stories, placed by which stories it covers: outlets close together run the same stories. Each dot is in the outlet's AllSides lean color, white when it isn't rated. The second view places them by how they word them: how close their stories and words are to the AP's and Reuters', and how heated their headlines are.
π‘ The first axis isn't left against right. Across, it runs from business, tech and world news to the political fight, and the partisan outlets of both sides sit together at the fight's end: they cover the same fight. Left and right part on the second axis: crime and immigration stories at the bottom, stories critical of Trump at the top.
π Point at or tap a dot for its outlet's card; click to keep it open.
- Left
- Lean left
- Center
- Lean right
- Right
- not rated
π§ How the map is made
ποΈ Which stories it covers: a correspondence analysis of outlets Γ stories (did the outlet run the story or not). The two axes drawn hold 5.2% and 3.8% of the differences between outlets. The maths leaves each axis' direction open, so the lean ratings set it: the end where outlets rated far left or far right gather is to the right, the end where left-rated ones gather is up.
πΆοΈ How it words them: across, the average rank among these outlets of the share of its stories a wire also ran, how near its headlines are to the wire's on those stories, and its vocabulary; up, the average rank of its loaded words, combat verbs, sensational words, anger and labels.
π·οΈ The types: Ward clusters on about fifty measures of what outlets do, each group of measures weighted alike. A type is shown when it holds together: sorted again a hundred times with a fifth of the outlets left out at random, it comes back at least three-quarters the same on average (clusterwise Jaccard). An outlet is given its type only when at least two of the three outlets it behaves most like share it, and a type named for a side only when it's rated on that side or not rated.
π― The beats: independent component analysis of the same outlets Γ stories table, which looks for groups of stories that rise together in a few outlets rather than for the directions of most difference. A beat is shown when it comes back in at least four of five reruns (each with a new start and a fifth of the stories left out) and when its ten defining stories' labels are closer in meaning than 95% of random sets of our stories: an outlet that ran few of our stories always stands apart, so that alone isn't a beat. Its name is a topic most of its stories share, or the stories themselves.
π§² The stories that pull each way
An outlet that runs these stories is drawn toward that end of the map. Each story's color says whose outlets ran it more: the share of the left-rated outlets on the map that ran it against the share of the right-rated ones. Hover or tap a story for both shares; click one to open its page.
- left-rated ran it more
- both alike
- right-rated ran it more
πΌ business, tech and world
the stories that pull outlets this way hardest, first; the bar is how many outlets on the map ran it
- βοΈ Meta introduces new nonvoting stock class to fund AI spending 18 of 83
- βοΈ Anthropic's IPO faces tempered expectations as growth slows 12 of 83
- βοΈ Meta announces $95 billion stock offering to fund AI expansion 11 of 83
- π« China's economy grows 4.5% in third quarter 10 of 83
- βοΈ Apple reports stronger-than-expected revenue in first earnings report under new CEO John Ternus 11 of 83
- βοΈ Microsoft stock rises on cloud revenue growth and earnings beat 6 of 83
- βοΈ General Motors moves stock listing from NYSE to Nasdaq 10 of 83
- π« Netflix reports Q3 revenue beat but warns of q4 slowdown and ad sales shortfall 11 of 83
π₯ the political fight
the stories that pull outlets this way hardest, first; the bar is how many outlets on the map ran it
- π Gavin Newsom says dsa will be mainstream in Democratic party 9 of 83
- π Abdul El-Sayed denies family ties to Muslim Brotherhood after relative's admission 12 of 83
- π ICE disputes 60 Minutes' deportation story with new details 8 of 83
- π JD Vance checks on woman who collapsed at rally, leads crowd in prayer 10 of 83
- βοΈ Abdul El-Sayed wins Michigan Senate race 53 of 83
- π« Supreme Court rules against Trump's voter suppression claims 6 of 83
- π Two arrested after car crash near White House 23 of 83
- βοΈ Lauren boebert's campaign investigates unusual voting patterns in tight race 10 of 83
π stories critical of Trump
the stories that pull outlets this way hardest, first; the bar is how many outlets on the map ran it
- βοΈ General Motors moves stock listing from NYSE to Nasdaq 10 of 83
- βοΈ Microsoft stock rises on cloud revenue growth and earnings beat 6 of 83
- π« CoreWeave's debt crisis spurs AI market concerns 11 of 83
- βοΈ Republicans face challenges in 2028 presidential race after midterm losses 83 of 83
- βοΈ Anthropic's IPO faces tempered expectations as growth slows 12 of 83
- βοΈ Fed officials signal possible half-point rate hike amid Rising inflation 8 of 83
- βοΈ Voters rejected data centers in many local elections 33 of 83
- π« Midterm results mark decline of Trump and Maga 12 of 83
π crime and immigration
the stories that pull outlets this way hardest, first; the bar is how many outlets on the map ran it
- π« Rays and Guardians split ALCS games 6 of 83
- βοΈ Helicopter crash near Miami leaves 1 dead 2 injured 14 of 83
- βοΈ ALCS Game 4 postponed due to rain, series resumes Saturday 9 of 83
- βοΈ 71-year-old man killed by 12-foot alligator while fishing in Florida 12 of 83
- βοΈ Texas man charged with murder aboard cruise ship 18 of 83
- βοΈ Chiefs sign former all-pro kicker Tucker to practice squad 11 of 83
- βοΈ Detroit Lions linebacker Jack Campbell reports full lower-body movement after neck injury 16 of 83
- βοΈ TWO college students found dead after hiking trip 9 of 83
π·οΈ Outlet types
Outlets sorted into types by what they do on their front pages, not by any rating: which stories they run and when, beside whom, how close to the wires, how they word their headlines, how often they rewrite them. Outlets shade into each other more than they fall into islands, so a type is shown only when it holds together each time we sort them again; among the big mainstream outlets the finer types don't, so those carry only the broad family, named for what it isn't. A "partisan web" is one side's own outlets, running the same fight-heavy stories as each other.
The most heated first: πΆοΈ the bar is how heated the type's middle outlet words its headlines (its percentile among the outlets on the map); π‘ the second, how close it is to the AP and Reuters. Hover or tap a type for what it does and its outlets.
- π¨ Right partisan web 11 outletsπ¨ Right partisan web
Heated wording, the most crime and immigration stories, and more stories that mostly right-leaning outlets run.
π§· Holds together: sorted again with some outlets left out, it keeps 98% of its outlets on average.
The Blaze, Breitbart, The Daily Caller, The Daily Wire, The Federalist, The Gateway Pundit, PJ Media, The Post Millennial, Red State, Townhall, The Western Journal
- π’ Left partisan web 9 outletsπ’ Left partisan web
Heated wording about Trump and the political fight, with the most quotes and little wire copy.
π§· Holds together: sorted again with some outlets left out, it keeps 85% of its outlets on average.
Crooks and Liars, The Daily Kos, MSNBC, Mother Jones, The New Republic, New York Magazine, Salon, Talking Points Memo, Vox
- π Left opinion 9 outletsπ Left opinion
Commentary on Trump, late to stories, and furthest from the wires' vocabulary.
π§· Holds together: sorted again with some outlets left out, it keeps 85% of its outlets on average.
Crooks and Liars, The Daily Kos, MSNBC, Mother Jones, The New Republic, New York Magazine, Salon, Talking Points Memo, Vox
- ποΈ Outside the partisan webs 39 outletsποΈ Outside the partisan webs
Everyone outside the two partisan webs, from the wires to cable news: a big, mixed group that runs more of the stories everyone runs. Not a mark of quality or lean; its look-alikes say more.
π§· Holds together: sorted again with some outlets left out, it keeps 85% of its outlets on average.
ABC News, AP, Axios, BBC, Bloomberg, Business Insider, CBS News, CNBC, CNN, Chicago Tribune, The Epoch Times, Financial Times, Forbes, The Hill, Independent Journal Review, Just the News, Los Angeles Times, Military.com, NBC News, NPR, The National Desk, New York Times, News Nation, Newsmax, Newsweek, One America News Network, PBS NewsHour, Reuters, Rolling Stone, Scripps News, Star Tribune, Straight Arrow News, Tampa Bay Times, The Wall Street Journal, Washington Examiner, The Washington Post, The Washington Sun, The Washington Times, Yahoo News
π― Beats
Where the map gives two broad directions, these are single outlets' own agendas: groups of our stories that one outlet or a few ran far more than the rest did. A beat is shown when it comes back each time we look again with part of the stories left out, and when its stories hang together; outlets with no beat of their own aren't listed. Hover or tap a beat for its stories.
- π― politics
Vox
MSNBC Β· shared with The Atlantic, Mother Jones, Talking Points Memo, PJ Media, The Daily Signal
2 outletsπ― politicsπ€ The Atlantic ran 4 of these 10 stories, 18.7Γ its usual rate; Mother Jones ran 5 of these 10 stories, 15Γ its usual rate; Talking Points Memo ran 4 of these 10 stories, 12.6Γ its usual rate; PJ Media ran 8 of these 10 stories, 12.6Γ its usual rate; The Daily Signal ran 7 of these 10 stories, 10.9Γ its usual rate.
π§· Came back in 80% of the looks again.
- π― politics
Salon Β· shared with New York Magazine, Talking Points Memo, MSNBC, The Daily Kos, The Daily Signal
1 outletπ― politicsπ€ New York Magazine ran 6 of these 10 stories, 21.3Γ its usual rate; Talking Points Memo ran 5 of these 10 stories, 15.8Γ its usual rate; MSNBC ran 5 of these 10 stories, 14.6Γ its usual rate; The Daily Kos ran 5 of these 10 stories, 13Γ its usual rate; The Daily Signal ran 7 of these 10 stories, 10.9Γ its usual rate.
π§· Came back in 90% of the looks again.
- π― politics
The Federalist Β· shared with The Daily Kos, The Daily Signal, PJ Media, The Blaze, Star Tribune
1 outletπ― politicsπ€ The Daily Kos ran 5 of these 10 stories, 13Γ its usual rate; The Daily Signal ran 8 of these 10 stories, 12.5Γ its usual rate; PJ Media ran 7 of these 10 stories, 11.1Γ its usual rate; The Blaze ran 9 of these 10 stories, 10Γ its usual rate; Star Tribune ran 4 of these 10 stories, 9.7Γ its usual rate.
π§· Came back in 90% of the looks again.
π Every outlet on the map
π‘ Wire: closer to the AP and Reuters than this share of the outlets here. πΆοΈ Heat: more heated wording than this share. Click a heading to sort.
- Outside the partisan webs
- Right partisan web
- Left opinion
- No settled type
From the study of Oct 27-28, rebuilt each day from the last 28 days; the methods log has the details. Outlets the site doesn't build stories from (most outlets outside the US and the UK) aren't on the map.