🧵 Saga file #172
Trump immigration policy
Nov 8, 9 PM ET to Nov 11, 5 PM ET · 🔴 on the front pages now
🧩 2 parts so far 📰 40 outlets carried a part ⚖️ 🫏17 · 7 · 16🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 2.8 days running so far 📺 40 min of TV captions 📻 8 radio newscasts 🧶 53 people retold it online
🧵 One running story, told across days: each part is a story of its own on the
front pages, joined to the others because our tools judged them one case, event or investigation as it
developed. A part can be joined wrongly; the saga tracker says how they're made.
📰 Spread
each part on the front pages, hour by hour
Nov 9 12 PM Nov 10 12 PM Nov 11 12 PM 19 38 Trump proposes amnesty deal with Democrats Trump says deportation policy may have been too tough
Front pages carrying each part at each hourly run, Nov 8, 9 PM to Nov 11, 5 PM ET (peak 38), stacked by part:
1 · 2
Nov 9 12 PM Nov 10 12 PM Nov 11 12 PM 1. Trump proposes amnesty deal with …Trump proposes amnesty deal with Democrats Trump proposes amnesty deal with Democrats: Nov 10, 2 PM to Nov 11, 6 AM ET, 9 outlets 2. Trump says deportation policy may…Trump says deportation policy may have been too tough Trump says deportation policy may have been too tough: Nov 8, 9 PM to Nov 11, 5 PM ET, 37 outlets 📺 TV CNN, Nov 11, 12:40 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 11, 12:40 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 11, 12:41 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 11, 12:41 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 11, 12:42 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 11, 12:42 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 11, 12:43 AM ET: MULLIN: TRUMP OPEN TO DACA COMPROMISE IF MAGA APPROVES CNN, Nov 8, 9:53 PM ET: TRUMP SAYS HE'D BE WILLING TO WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 8, 9:54 PM ET: TRUMP SAYS HE'D BE WILLING TO WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 8, 10:04 PM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 8, 10:08 PM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 8, 10:08 PM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 8, 10:09 PM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 9, 12:04 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 9, 12:05 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 9, 12:06 AM ET: TRUMP SAYS HE'D BE WILLING TO WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 9, 12:07 AM ET: TRUMP SAYS HE'D BE WILLING TO WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 9, 12:07 AM ET: TRUMP SAYS HE'D BE WILLING TO WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 9, 12:08 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 9, 12:08 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM CNN, Nov 9, 12:09 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY ULTIMATELY HURT HIM Fox News, Nov 9, 12:31 AM ET: TRUMP SAYS HIS DEPORTATION POLICY MIGHT HAVE BEEN "TOO TOUGH" IN 60 MINUTES INTERVIEW CNN, Nov 9, 2:05 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS CNN, Nov 9, 2:33 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS CNN, Nov 9, 2:33 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS CNN, Nov 9, 2:34 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS CNN, Nov 9, 2:34 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS CNN, Nov 9, 4:29 AM ET: TRUMP: "TOO TOUGH" DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS CNN, Nov 9, 5:01 AM ET: Trump: Deportation Policy Hurt GOP In Midterms CNN, Nov 9, 5:02 AM ET: Trump: Deportation Policy Hurt GOP In Midterms CNN, Nov 9, 5:02 AM ET: Trump: "Too Tough" Deportation Policy Hurt GOP In Midterms Fox News, Nov 9, 5:14 AM ET: TRUMP: IMMIGRATION CRACKDOWN HELPED AND HURT MSNOW, Nov 9, 5:17 AM ET: TRUMP: DEPORTATION POLICY MIGHT HAVE BEEN "TOO MSNOW, Nov 9, 5:18 AM ET: TRUMP: DEPORTATION POLICY MIGHT HAVE BEEN "TOO CNN, Nov 9, 5:32 AM ET: Trump: Deportation Policy Hurt GOP In Midterms CNN, Nov 9, 5:32 AM ET: Trump: Deportation Policy Hurt GOP In Midterms CNN, Nov 9, 5:32 AM ET: Trump: "Too Tough" Deportation Policy Hurt GOP In Midterms CNN, Nov 9, 6:01 AM ET: AS DEMS LAY OUT PRIORITIES, TRUMP SAYS HE'S OPEN TO WORK WITH THEM CNN, Nov 9, 6:02 AM ET: AS DEMS LAY OUT PRIORITIES, TRUMP SAYS HE'S OPEN TO WORK WITH THEM CNN, Nov 9, 6:03 AM ET: TRUMP HOPES TO FIND COMMON GROUND WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 9, 6:03 AM ET: AS DEMS LAY OUT PRIORITIES, TRUMP SAYS HE'S OPEN TO WORK WITH THEM CNN, Nov 9, 6:03 AM ET: TRUMP HOPES TO FIND COMMON GROUND WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 9, 6:03 AM ET: AS DEMS LAY OUT PRIORITIES, TRUMP SAYS HE'S OPEN TO WORK WITH THEM CNN, Nov 9, 6:05 AM ET: TRUMP HOPES TO FIND COMMON GROUND WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 9, 6:05 AM ET: AS DEMS LAY OUT PRIORITIES, TRUMP SAYS HE'S OPEN TO WORK WITH THEM CNN, Nov 9, 6:05 AM ET: AS DEMS LAY OUT PRIORITIES, TRUMP SAYS HE'S OPEN TO WORK WITH THEM CNN, Nov 9, 6:06 AM ET: TRUMP HOPES TO FIND COMMON GROUND WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION Fox News, Nov 9, 9:04 AM ET: TRUMP SAYS DEPORTATION POLICY WAS 'TOO TOUGH' Fox News, Nov 9, 9:05 AM ET: TRUMP SAYS DEPORTATION POLICY WAS "TOO TOUGH" MSNOW, Nov 9, 12:07 PM ET: TRUMP ADMITS DEPORTATION POLICY WAS "TOO TOUGH" BBC News, Nov 9, 3:11 PM ET: Trump says would work with Democrats on immigration BBC News, Nov 9, 3:11 PM ET: Trump says immigration crackdown was 'too tough' BBC News, Nov 9, 3:12 PM ET: Trump says immigration crackdown was 'too tough' BBC News, Nov 9, 3:12 PM ET: Trump says would work with Democrats on immigration BBC News, Nov 9, 3:13 PM ET: Trump says would work with Democrats on immigration BBC News, Nov 9, 3:13 PM ET: Trump says immigration crackdown was 'too tough' BBC News, Nov 9, 3:14 PM ET: Trump says immigration crackdown was 'too tough' BBC News, Nov 9, 3:14 PM ET: Trump says would work with Democrats on immigration Fox News, Nov 9, 4:55 PM ET: TRUMP: THERE WON'T BE AMNESTY Fox News, Nov 9, 5:16 PM ET: "TOO TOUGH". TRUMP CONFESSES DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS Fox News, Nov 9, 5:17 PM ET: "TOO TOUGH". TRUMP CONFESSES DEPORTATION POLICY HURT GOP IN MIDTERMS Fox News, Nov 9, 6:09 PM ET: LET'S MAKE A DEAL. TRUMP REJECTS POTENTIAL AMNESTY FOR ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS BBC News, Nov 9, 6:38 PM ET: Trump says his immigration crackdown was 'too tough' Fox News, Nov 9, 7:03 PM ET: GOP'S POST-ELECTION PIVOT: A DACA DEAL? Fox News, Nov 9, 7:04 PM ET: TRUMP RULES OUT AMNESTY, BUT WHAT'S ON THE TABLE? Fox News, Nov 9, 8:07 PM ET: TRUMP: I'D WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION Fox News, Nov 9, 8:08 PM ET: TRUMP: I'D WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION CNN, Nov 10, 1:06 AM ET: TRUMP: DEPORTATIONS WERE "TOO TOUGH," COST ELECTION CNN, Nov 10, 1:07 AM ET: TRUMP: DEPORTATIONS WERE "TOO TOUGH," COST ELECTION Fox News, Nov 10, 1:07 AM ET: TRUMP: I'D WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION Fox News, Nov 10, 1:08 AM ET: TRUMP: I'D WORK WITH DEMS ON IMMIGRATION Fox News, Nov 10, 1:08 AM ET: IMMIGRATION DEAL IS POLITICAL SUICIDE CNN, Nov 10, 1:14 AM ET: TRUMP: DEPORTATIONS WERE "TOO TOUGH," COST ELECTION CNN, Nov 10, 1:15 AM ET: TRUMP: DEPORTATIONS WERE "TOO TOUGH," COST ELECTION Fox News, Nov 10, 1:31 AM ET: IMMIGRATION DEAL IS POLITICAL SUICIDE MSNOW, Nov 10, 6:41 AM ET: DEMS PLAN REVERSAL OF TX HARD-LINE IMMIGRATION Fox News, Nov 10, 7:03 AM ET: TRUMP: WE HAVE A VERY STRONG DEPORTATION POLICY Fox News, Nov 10, 9:41 AM ET: TRUMP REJECTS AMNESTY FOR ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS 📻 radio NPR News Now, Nov 9, 12:09 PM ET NPR News Now, Nov 9, 9:10 AM ET ABC News Update, Nov 9, 6:32 AM ET NPR News Now, Nov 9, 6:10 AM ET NPR News Now, Nov 9, 5:09 AM ET ABC News Update, Nov 9, 5:05 AM ET NPR News Now, Nov 9, 2:09 AM ET ABC News Update, Nov 8, 10:32 PM ET 🧶 online 🧶retold online (the day's report) 🧶retold online (the day's report) 🧶retold online (the day's report)
Its parts in the order of their latest news, each from when we first saw it on a front page to when we last
did; beneath, the TV captions, radio newscasts and retellings, each in the color of the part it was
about. Hover for details.
🧩 How it's been told
the stories under the saga, day by day, from our motif index: each day its most-told, wider for more tellers, colored by genre (✨ new to the saga that day)
🎭 Archetypes a kind of person
📜 Plots what happened
🪨 Beliefs a premise
🕵️ Theories what people think is behind it
🗣️ Arguments a move in an argument
⚪ left white, the smaller genres: 📣 Exhortations a call to act
Tue Nov 10
They backed down 2 ✨ Immigration policy backlash 1 Immigration enforcement gone too far 1 ✨ Watch what he does, not what he says 1
Mon Nov 9
✨ Immigration enforcement gone too far 1 ✨ They backed down 1 ✨ Abolish, don't reform 1
🧶 Retelling
what people online made of it, part by part
Trump says his deportations may have been too tough and opens the door to a deal, the day he made Stephen Miller chief of staff. told by 27 people, on “Trump says deportation policy may have been too tough”
Donald Trump said his deportation policy might have been too tough for voters in the election. told by 19 people, on “Trump says deportation policy may have been too tough”
ICE should be abolished. told by 7 people, on “Trump says deportation policy may have been too tough”