← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #951

Appeals court rejects DOJ request to set aside California ballots

Oct 25, 10 PM ET to Nov 1, 9 PM ET · 2 outlets not rated for lean

📰 read it at: HuffPostMother JonesRaw StoryThe GuardianABC NewsAPAxiosCBS NewsCNBCCNNLos Angeles TimesNBC NewsNPRNew York TimesPBS NewsHourThe IndependentThe Washington PostYahoo NewsBloombergNewsweekReasonReutersScripps NewsStraight Arrow NewsThe HillJust the NewsThe Epoch TimesThe Washington TimesWashington ExaminerBreitbartFox NewsIJRNew York PostNewsmaxRed StateThe BlazeThe Gateway PunditThe National DeskTalking Points MemoThe Washington Sun

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 25, 2 PM ETfirst on a front page: Independent Journal Review
  2. Oct 25, 9 PM ETthe news that day, The Washington Sun:“Appeals Court Questions Trump Administration’s Bid to Block 20,000 California Ballots”
  3. Oct 25, 10 PM ETfirst on the radio: ABC News Update
  4. Oct 26, 9 PM ETfirst on TV: MSNOW
  5. Oct 26, 10 PM ETthe news that day, The Washington Times:“Appeals court rejects Trump bid to block 20,000 ballots of suspected noncitizens”
  6. Oct 27, 10 PM ETthe news that day, New York Times:“Judge Questions Trump Administration’s Need to Target Noncitizen Voters”
  7. Oct 28, 9 PM ETthe news that day, The Washington Sun:“Federal Judge Rules DOJ Cannot Segregate California Ballots”
  8. Oct 29, 2 AM ETthe news that day, CNBC:“Judge says Trump's bid to set aside California ballots would ‘wreak havoc’ on democracy”
  9. Oct 29, 8 PM ETpeak: on 31 front pages at once
  10. Oct 30, 10 PM ETthe news that day, The Hill:“Appeals court rules against Trump — again — on California ballots”
  11. Oct 31, 10 PM ETthe news that day, Independent Journal Review:“Courts Block DOJ Election Actions in California”

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

⏱️ Who stayed on it

+63 h 🐘 right

Right outlets kept it on their front pages a median 63 hours longer than left outlets (110 hours against 47).

📡 Wire copy

2 outlets ran the AP, Reuters headline nearly word for word

CNBC, HuffPost

💬 Quoted

  1. “jeopardize”1
  2. “Not Credible,”1
  3. “wreak havoc”2
  4. “Wreak Havoc”1

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

🗣️ Only one side says

  • 🫏 left
  • court declines
  • 🐘 right
  • nothing of its own

phrases three or more outlets on one side used and none on the other

📌 Linked by aggregators

2 Google News · Political Wire

aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)

✏️ 29 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • ABC News (6 wordings): “Appeals court hears arguments in Trump admin's voting suit against California” → “Judge rejects Trump admin request for order to segregate 20,000 Calif. ballots”
  • AP (2 wordings): “Appeals court declines to block California from counting 20,000 disputed ballots” → “Special master could evaluate Justice Department's claims of noncitizens on California voter rolls”
  • Bloomberg (2 wordings): “DOJ Bid for Fast Ruling in California Voting Case Rejected” → “Judge Says US Bid to Block 20,000 Votes Would ‘Wreak Havoc’”
  • Breitbart (3 wordings): “Ninth Circuit Won’t Order California to Set Aside Noncitizen Ballots” → “Federal Judge Blocks DOJ Effort to Sequester 20,000 California Ballots”
  • CBS News (3 wordings): “Court dismisses DOJ's request to force California to set aside ballots” → “Appeals court rejects DOJ bid to set aside disputed California ballots”
  • CNBC (2 wordings): “Judge says Trump's bid to set aside California ballots would ‘wreak havoc’ on democracy” → “Trump admin again loses bid to block California from counting alleged noncitizen votes”
  • CNN (8 wordings): “Judges skeptical of Trump administration effort to force California to set aside mail ballots” → “Justice Department tells judge it may bring more charges against James Comey”
  • Fox News (2 wordings): “Judge rejects DOJ request to block California from immediately counting ballots linked to alleged noncitizens” → “Clinton-appointed judge rejects DOJ bid to stop 20,000 alleged noncitizens' votes”
  • HuffPost (5 wordings): “Trump Administration Loses Push To Block California Votes From Alleged Noncitizens” → “In Setback For Trump’s Justice Department, Appeals Court Rejects Request For California To Set Aside 20,000 Disputed Ballots”
  • Independent Journal Review (4 wordings): “Appeals Court to Hear California Ballot Dispute” → “Courts Block DOJ Election Actions in California”
  • Just the News (4 wordings): “Federal appeals court appears skeptical of DOJ lawsuit over ballots allegedly sent to noncitizens” → “Appeals court again rejects Trump admin's bid to separate 20K CA ballots”
  • Los Angeles Times (5 wordings): “9th Circuit panel questions basis for feds’ request to block 20,000 California ballots” → “9th Circuit again denies Trump administration request to block 20,000 California ballots”
  • NBC News (5 wordings): “BREAKING: Judge denies Trump administration request to segregate alleged noncitizen ballots in California” → “Appeals court again rejects DOJ’s bid to segregate over 20,000 alleged noncitizen ballots in California”
  • New York Post (3 wordings): “Feds appeal after judge rejects bid to stop California from counting 20K disputed ballots” → “Judge rejects DOJ appeal to stop California from counting 20K disputed ballots”
  • New York Times (3 wordings): “Appeals Court Declines to Intervene in California Ballot Lawsuit” → “Judge Rejects Trump Officials’ Bid to Set Aside California Ballots”
  • Newsmax (6 wordings): “9th Circuit Questions DOJ Bid to Block Calif. Ballots” → “9th Circuit Rejects DOJ Bid on California Ballots”
  • Red State (5 wordings): “BREAKING 9th Circuit Rules on Trump DOJ's Appeal Regarding CA Mail Ballots to Likely Noncitizens” → “Judge Issues Scathing Ruling on Emergency Motion to Sequester 20,000 California Ballots”
  • Reuters (6 wordings): “US appeals court appears skeptical of Trump DOJ's lawsuit over California voter rolls” → “Court rejects Trump admin bid to block California vote count, cites disenfranchisement risk”
  • Scripps News (4 wordings): “Court appears skeptical of Trump administration's California ballot lawsuit” → “Appeals court rejects DOJ's demand for California to set aside disputed ballots”
  • Straight Arrow News (3 wordings): “Appeals court questions DOJ’s challenge to California mail-in ballots” → “Judge blocks California ballot challenge, questions evidence against 20,000 voters”
  • The Blaze (2 wordings): “9th Circuit rejects Trump DOJ's emergency motion over 20,000 questionable voters in California” → “9th Circuit denies Trump DOJ's demand for California to set aside likely noncitizen ballots — but it's not over”
  • The Epoch Times (5 wordings): “Appeals Court Raises Doubt Over Trump Admin’s Ballot Lawsuit Against California” → “Appeals Court Rejects DOJ Request for California to Set Aside 20,000 Ballots”
  • The Gateway Pundit (5 wordings): “DEVELOPING: Ninth Circuit to Rule on DOJ’s Bid to Block 20,000 Illegal California Votes From Being Counted – Panel Reportedly Skeptical of DOJ” → “Trump Reacts to Appeals Court’s Decision to Block DOJ’s Last-Minute Bid to Force California to Remove 20,000 Ballots Mailed to Non-Citizens”
  • The Guardian (3 wordings): “Judge rebuffs Trump DoJ’s bid to order California to set aside 20,000 ballots” → “Appeals court shoots down Trump administration’s bid to block 20,000 California ballots”
  • The Hill (2 wordings): “DOJ’s California ballot fight rejected by another judge” → “Appeals court rules against Trump — again — on California ballots”
  • The Independent (2 wordings): “Trump’s bid to toss 20,000 California ballots could ‘jeopardize’ midterm elections, appeals court warns” → “Trump’s attempt to toss California ballots could ‘jeopardize’ midterms”
  • The Washington Sun (5 wordings): “Appeals Court Questions Trump Administration’s Bid to Block 20,000 California Ballots” → “Appeals Court Again Denies DOJ’s California Noncitizen Ballot Push”
  • The Washington Times (3 wordings): “Appeals court rejects Trump bid to block 20,000 ballots of suspected noncitizens” → “Trump suffers another loss in effort to block California ballots”
  • Washington Examiner (6 wordings): “Appeals court rejects DOJ’s expedited bid to set aside 20,000 California mail ballots” → “Appeals court rejects DOJ effort to set aside 20,000 mail-in ballots”
📰 Every outlet's headline 40left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. 🫏 CNN 43 min
  2. 🫏 MSNOW 17 min
  3. 🐘 Fox News 9 min

📻 On the radio

hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order

  1. 🫏 NPR News Now 22× · 🥇 led 7
  2. 🫏 ABC News Update 19× · 🥇 led 2

🎙️ On the shows

podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation

  1. 🫏 MeidasTouch 2
  2. ⚖️ Reuters World News 1

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces

  1. 🕵️ Just Security 1

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

  • 🧩 Solution in search of a problem 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Voter fraud
    as told: “A federal judge rejected the Trump administration's attempt to force California to set aside 20,000 ballots based on unproven claims of noncitizen voters.”
  • 🧩 Voter fraud 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Solution in search of a problem
    as told: “A federal appeals court expressed skepticism toward the Trump administration's lawsuit seeking to set aside 20,000 California mail-in ballots suspected of being sent to noncitizens.” and 2 more

🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🗣️ Names in it

California9th CircuitTrump administration

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🧵 DOJ California voter fraud case

  1. DOJ warns California election officials of legal risks for counting suspected noncitizen ballots

    Oct 17, 9 PM ET

  2. DOJ sues California over suspected noncitizen voters

    Oct 14, 11 AM ET

  3. DOJ charges 28 noncitizens in California voter fraud case

    Oct 19, 2 PM ET

  4. Justice Department seeks court order over alleged noncitizen voters in California

    Oct 21, 12 PM ET

  5. DOJ charges 48 noncitizens with election crimes

    Oct 26, 6 PM ET

  6. Judge questions doj's claims of noncitizens on California voter rolls

    Oct 23, 9 PM ET

  7. Justice Department subpoenas California election officials in voter rolls investigation

    Oct 29, 7 PM ET

  8. Appeals court rejects DOJ request to set aside California ballots (this story)

    Oct 25, 10 PM ET

  9. Analysis finds over 40% of names on DOJ list not on California voter rolls

    Nov 1, 1 PM ET

  10. Ninth Circuit allows Trump administration to request noncitizen ballot separation

    Nov 3, 8 PM ET

  11. Supreme court rejects Trump administration bid to set aside California ballots

    Nov 2, 1 PM ET

  12. Justice Department drops lawsuit against California over disputed ballots

    Nov 6, 11 PM ET