← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #897

Judge questions doj's claims of noncitizens on California voter rolls

Oct 23, 9 PM ET to Oct 28, 5 PM ET · 1 outlet not rated for lean

📰 read it at: HuffPostCBS NewsCNNLos Angeles TimesNew York TimesPBS NewsHourReutersStraight Arrow NewsThe HillThe Epoch TimesFox NewsNew York PostNewsmaxRed StateThe Daily SignalThe Gateway PunditThe Washington Sun

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 22, 4 PM ETfirst on a front page: The Daily Signal
  2. Oct 23, 12 AM ETthe news that day, The Hill:“DOJ asks appeals court to intervene for California mail-in ballot lawsuit”
  3. Oct 24, 12 AM ETfirst on TV: CNN
  4. Oct 24, 6 AM ETpeak: on 13 front pages at once
  5. Oct 24, 11 AM ETfirst on the radio: NPR News Now
  6. Oct 24, 4 PM ETthe news that day, Reuters:“Trump administration demands county election officials identify noncitizen voters in California, report says”

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

📡 Wire copy

1 outlet ran the Reuters headline nearly word for word

New York Times

💬 Quoted

  1. “Noncitizen”1
  2. “likely”1
  3. “This is not normal”1

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

🗣️ Only one side says

  • 🫏 left
  • california counties
  • aside ballots
  • 🐘 right
  • nothing of its own

phrases three or more outlets on one side used and none on the other

📌 Linked by aggregators

1 Google News

aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)

✏️ 5 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • Red State (2 wordings): “NEW: DOJ Moves to Bypass Federal Judge in CA Mail Ballot Case, Files Emergency Motion at 9th Circuit” → “UPDATE: 9th Circuit Orders CA to Respond to DOJ's Emergency Motion in Alleged Noncitizen Ballot Case”
  • Reuters (5 wordings): “Justice Department asks appeals court to intervene in California ballot case” → “US Justice Dept demands California counties help identify suspected noncitizen voters - Reuters”
  • The Daily Signal (2 wordings): “EXCLUSIVE: What Did California Do With DOJ’s List of 20,000 Potential Noncitizens? Election Integrity Group Seeks Records” → “California’s 20,000-Ballot Fight: Judges Press DOJ Over Suspected Noncitizen Voters”
  • The Gateway Pundit (2 wordings): “DOJ Rushes to Block California From Counting 20,000 Ballots Tied to Suspected Noncitizens Before Votes Are Mixed Forever” → “Clinton Judge Issues Warning to DOJ During Hearing on Effort to Force California to Remove 20,000 Ballots Mailed to Non-Citizens”
  • The Hill (2 wordings): “DOJ asks appeals court to intervene for California mail-in ballot lawsuit” → “DOJ demands California counties identify noncitizen voters: Reports”
📰 Every outlet's headline 17left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. 🐘 Fox News 4 min
  2. 🫏 CNN 3 min
  3. 🫏 MSNOW 82 s

📻 On the radio

hourly newscasts that carried it, by show; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order

  1. 🫏 ABC News Update 12× · 🥇 led 8
  2. 🫏 NPR News Now 2× · 🥇 led 1

🎙️ On the shows

podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation

  1. 🐘 Ben Shapiro 1

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces

🕵️🤷 No investigator or satirist matched to it yet.

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

  • 🧩 Second-class citizens 🧶 online
    as told: “A birth certificate for someone born in the U.S. makes them an American citizen.”
  • 🧩 Solution in search of a problem 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Voter fraud
    as told: “The Trump administration is using unproven claims of noncitizen voting to attempt to meddle in and sideline ballots in California and Washington.”
  • 🧩 Voter suppression 🧶 online
    ↔️ its answer: Ballot security, Voter fraud
    as told: “The Trump administration is using unproven claims of noncitizen voting to attempt to meddle in and sideline ballots in California and Washington.”

🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🗣️ Names in it

Justice DepartmentCalifornia9th Circuit

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🧵 DOJ California voter fraud case

  1. DOJ warns California election officials of legal risks for counting suspected noncitizen ballots

    Oct 17, 9 PM ET

  2. DOJ sues California over suspected noncitizen voters

    Oct 14, 11 AM ET

  3. DOJ charges 28 noncitizens in California voter fraud case

    Oct 19, 2 PM ET

  4. Justice Department seeks court order over alleged noncitizen voters in California

    Oct 21, 12 PM ET

  5. DOJ charges 48 noncitizens with election crimes

    Oct 26, 6 PM ET

  6. Judge questions doj's claims of noncitizens on California voter rolls (this story)

    Oct 23, 9 PM ET

  7. Justice Department subpoenas California election officials in voter rolls investigation

    Oct 29, 7 PM ET

  8. Appeals court rejects DOJ request to set aside California ballots

    Oct 25, 10 PM ET

  9. Analysis finds over 40% of names on DOJ list not on California voter rolls

    Nov 1, 1 PM ET

  10. Ninth Circuit allows Trump administration to request noncitizen ballot separation

    Nov 3, 8 PM ET

  11. Supreme court rejects Trump administration bid to set aside California ballots

    Nov 2, 1 PM ET

  12. Justice Department drops lawsuit against California over disputed ballots

    Nov 6, 11 PM ET