← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #342

U.S. plans to livestream execution By firing squad draw bipartisan and international criticism

Oct 11, 4 PM ET to Oct 12, 5 AM ET

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 11, 4 PM ETpeak: on 7 front pages
  2. Oct 11, 9 PM ETfirst on TV: MSNOW
  3. Oct 12, 9 AM ETretold online by 46 people

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

Oct 11, 6 PM8 PM10 PMOct 122 AM4 AM47leftcenterright
Front pages carrying it at each hourly run, Oct 11, 4 PM to Oct 12, 5 AM ET (peak 7), by the outlets' lean: left · center · right
Oct 10, 6 PMOct 116 AM12 PM6 PMOct 126 AMLos Angeles TimesLos Angeles TimesLos Angeles Times, Oct 9, 4:00 PM ET: U.S. plan to livestream execution by firing squad draws bipartisan, international outrageCS MonitorThe Christian Science MonitorThe Christian Science Monitor, Oct 10, 6:00 AM ET: Botched execution and talk of livestream reignite death penalty debate By Patrik Jonsson / 4 minNewsmaxNewsmaxNewsmax, Oct 10, 2:02 PM ET: GOP Split on Livestreaming Fort Hood ExecutionThe Washington TimesThe Washington TimesThe Washington Times, Oct 10, 2:02 PM ET: ‘Barbaric spectacle’ or ‘no-brainer’? Lawmakers split over livestreaming an executionThe HillThe HillThe Hill, Oct 10, 6:00 PM ET: GOP lawmakers push back on Hegseth decision to livestream executionYahoo NewsYahoo NewsYahoo News, Oct 10, 7:00 PM ET: Republicans break with Hegseth over plan to livestream Fort Hood executionIJRIndependent Journal ReviewIndependent Journal Review, Oct 11, 8:00 AM ET: Botched Execution, Planned Livestream Reignite US Death-Penalty Debate📺 TVMSNOW, 9:00 PM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 9:01 PM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 9:01 PM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 9:02 PM ET: WORLD CONDEMNS U.S. PLAN TO LIVESTREAM EXECUTIONMSNOW, 9:02 PM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 9:02 PM ET: WORLD CONDEMNS U.S. PLAN TO LIVESTREAM EXECUTIONCNN, 9:37 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:41 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 9:42 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 9:43 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 9:43 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONFox News, 9:43 PM ET: CONVICTED MURDERER SURVIVES LETHAL INJECTIONCNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 9:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:46 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:47 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:47 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:47 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 9:47 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 9:48 PM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONFox News, 9:48 PM ET: JUDGE REOPENS PIKE'S CASE AGAINST LETHAL INJECTIONCNN, 11:11 PM ET: IS CORRUPTION GOING TO BE A DRIVING ISSUE IN THE MIDTERMS?. David Axelrod | @WN Chief Political AnalystCNN, 11:17 PM ET: IS CORRUPTION GOING TO BE A DRIVING ISSUE IN THE MIDTERMS?. David Axelrod | @WN Chief Political AnalystCNN, 11:19 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:44 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:45 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:46 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:47 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:47 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 11:47 PM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONMSNOW, 12:00 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 12:01 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 12:02 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDFox News, 12:47 AM ET: LEGAL BATTLE AHEAD FOLLOWING BOTCHED TN EXECUTIONCNN, 1:19 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:36 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:41 AM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 1:42 AM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 1:42 AM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 1:43 AM ET: TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTIONCNN, 1:44 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:44 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:44 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:44 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:45 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:45 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:45 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:47 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:47 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONCNN, 1:47 AM ET: TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTIONMSNOW, 4:00 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 4:01 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 4:01 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 4:02 AM ET: WORLD CONDEMNS U.S. PLAN TO LIVESTREAM EXECUTIONMSNOW, 4:02 AM ET: SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMEDMSNOW, 4:02 AM ET: WORLD CONDEMNS U.S. PLAN TO LIVESTREAM EXECUTIONFox News, 4:43 AM ET: CONVICTED MURDERER SURVIVES LETHAL INJECTIONFox News, 4:48 AM ET: JUDGE REOPENS PIKE'S CASE AGAINST LETHAL INJECTION🧶 online🧶found retold online (the day's report)
Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not rated); a dot marks a new headline. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it (bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details.

💬 quoted: “Barbaric spectacle” “no-brainer”

Every outlet's first headline (7), left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

CNN21 min
MSNOW6 min
Fox News2 min
  • TRUMP BACKS OFF "APPROVAL" OF PENTAGON'S PUBLIC EXECUTION CNN, 14 min
  • TRUMP REVERSES HIMSELF ON MIDTERM ADS, MAIL VOTING, EXECUTION CNN, 6 min
  • SEC. REGOETH ANNOUNCES EXECUTION WILL BE LIVESTREAMED MSNOW, 4 min
  • WORLD CONDEMNS U.S. PLAN TO LIVESTREAM EXECUTION MSNOW, 2 min
  • CONVICTED MURDERER SURVIVES LETHAL INJECTION Fox News, 73 s
  • JUDGE REOPENS PIKE'S CASE AGAINST LETHAL INJECTION Fox News, 54 s
  • IS CORRUPTION GOING TO BE A DRIVING ISSUE IN THE MIDTERMS?. David Axelrod | @WN Chief Political Analyst CNN, 33 s
  • LEGAL BATTLE AHEAD FOLLOWING BOTCHED TN EXECUTION Fox News, 7 s

🎙️ Shows, investigators, satire

🃏 NewsThump NewsThump NewsThump NewsThump

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧶 Retold online

  • Livestreaming Nidal Hasan's execution would restore American values, or shows how barbaric the country has become. Oct 12: told by 46 people (same issue)

On Folklore: the latest in full, with their motifs and who is telling them.

🗣️ names in it: Fort Hood

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🧵 Fort Hood execution debate

  1. Trump approves public execution of Fort Hood shooter

    Oct 11, 4 PM ET

  2. U.S. plans to livestream execution By firing squad draw bipartisan and international criticism (this story)

    Oct 11, 4 PM ET

  3. Pope denounces death penalty as U.S. plans livestreamed execution

    Oct 10, 2 PM ET

  4. Fort Hood survivors criticize plan to livestream Hasan's execution

    Oct 13, 1 AM ET

  5. Trump cancels livestream of Fort Hood shooter's execution

    Oct 5, 9 PM ET