BND - NYC Mayor Mamdani criticizes Israel on October 7 anniversary, faces backlash

🗞️ Story file #195

NYC Mayor Mamdani criticizes Israel on October 7 anniversary, faces backlash

Oct 7, 2 PM ET to Oct 9, 1 PM ET

18outlets carried it
🫏6 · 0 · 12🐘left · center · right
2 dayson the front pages
16front pages at once, at its peak
83 minof TV captions
3 of 3parts of a saga

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

Oct 7, 2 PM ETfirst on a front page: Mediaite
Oct 7, 2 PM ETfirst on TV: Fox News
Oct 8, 10 AM ETpeak: on 16 front pages

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

Front pages carrying it at each hourly run, Oct 7, 2 PM to Oct 9, 1 PM ET (peak 16), by the outlets' lean: left · right

Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not rated); a dot marks a new headline. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it (bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details.

📌 linked by aggregators: Google News

💬 quoted: “genocide” “Cannot give Jewish New Yorkers even a single day to mourn” “traitor” “Appropriating the trauma” “Hijacks” “Shame On You” “genocide,” 3 “apartheid”

🗣️ only one side says: 🐘 mamdani doubles

✏️ 10 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)

Just the News (2 wordings): “Mamdani marks Oct. 7 by accusing Israel of genocide, prompts backlash” → “NYC Mayor Mamdani booed at Oct. 7 vigil, called 'traitor' by pro-Palestinian protesters”
New York Magazine (3 wordings): “Mamdani Couldn’t Resist Attacking Israel in October 7 Statement This won’t do much to repair his relationship with New York’s Jewish Establishment.” → “Mamdani Couldn’t Resist Attacking Israel in October 7 Statement”
New York Post (4 wordings): “Mamdani’s tone-deaf Oct. 7 post attacks Israel for ‘ongoing genocide,’ sparks outrage” → “Mamdani booed, berated by anti-Israel protesters waving Hamas flags at NYC Oct. 7 memorial”
New York Times (3 wordings): “Mamdani Draws Anger With Oct. 7 Statement Denouncing Israel’s Gaza Attacks” → “Mamdani Stands By His Handling of Oct. 7 Anniversary After Emotional Day”
Newsmax (3 wordings): “Israeli Consul Ofir Akunis Tells Newsmax: ‘Shame on You, Mr. Mayor’ Mamdani” → “NYC's Mamdani Slammed Across Political Spectrum Over Oct. 7 Message”
The Daily Wire (2 wordings): “Mamdani Marks October 7 By Taking Another Shot At Israel” → “Mamdani Gets A Taste Of The Anti-Israel Mob At October 7 Vigil”
The Post Millennial (2 wordings): “Mamdani uses Oct. 7 anniversary to accuse Israel of 'genocide,' 'apartheid'” → “Mamdani doubles down on Oct. 7 remarks accusing Israel of 'genocide' despite bipartisan condemnation”
The Western Journal (2 wordings): “Mamdani Releases Statement Remembering Oct. 7, but Spends 75 Percent of His Words Defending Hamas' Actions” → “Watch: Mamdani Doubles Down on His Anti-Israel Oct. 7 Statement When Confronted by Reporter”
Townhall (2 wordings): “Mamdani Under Fire for His Plans on October 7 Anniversary” → “Mamdani Under Fire for His Plans on October 7 Anniversary Jeff Charles”
Washington Examiner (6 wordings): “Mamdani calls out Israel’s ‘genocide’ in Gaza on third anniversary of Oct. 7 terrorist attacks” → “Mamdani calls out Israel’s ‘genocide’ in Gaza on third anniversary of Oct. 7 attacks”

Every outlet's first headline (18), left to right by AllSides rating

New York Magazine Mamdani Couldn’t Resist Attacking Israel in October 7 Statement This won’t do much to repair his relationship with New York’s Jewish Establishment. Oct 7, 4 PM ET
CBS News Mamdani criticized for statement mourning Oct. 7 and condemning Israel Oct 7, 9 PM ET
CNN On the 3rd anniversary of October 7 attacks, Mamdani draws ire as he accuses Israel of genocide and war crimes Oct 8, 7 AM ET
Mediaite Mamdani’s October 7th Anniversary Message Sparks Fury on Left and Right: ‘Shame On You’ Oct 7, 2 PM ET
New York Times Mamdani Draws Anger With Oct. 7 Statement Denouncing Israel’s Gaza Attacks Oct 7, 5 PM ET
The Washington Post Mamdani defends Oct. 7 message that angered Jewish leaders, unnerved some Democrats Oct 8, 7 PM ET
Just the News Mamdani marks Oct. 7 by accusing Israel of genocide, prompts backlash Oct 7, 2 PM ET
The Epoch Times Mamdani Faces Bipartisan Backlash Over Criticism of Israel on Oct. 7 Oct 9, 12 AM ET
The Washington Times Zohran Mamdani uses Oct. 7 commemoration message to criticize Israel for ‘genocide’ in Gaza Oct 7, 5 PM ET
Washington Examiner Mamdani calls out Israel’s ‘genocide’ in Gaza on third anniversary of Oct. 7 terrorist attacks Oct 7, 10 AM ET
New York Post Mamdani’s tone-deaf Oct. 7 post attacks Israel for ‘ongoing genocide,’ sparks outrage Oct 7, 11 AM ET
Newsmax Israeli Consul Ofir Akunis Tells Newsmax: ‘Shame on You, Mr. Mayor’ Mamdani Oct 7, 6 PM ET
The Daily Signal BREAKING: Mamdani Marks Oct. 7 Tragedy With ‘Genocide’ Accusation Against Israel Oct 7, 11 AM ET
The Daily Wire Mamdani Marks October 7 By Taking Another Shot At Israel Oct 7, 1 PM ET
The Gateway Pundit Disgusting: NYC Mayor Mamdani Uses Oct. 7 Message to Attack Israel Oct 7, 12 PM ET
The Post Millennial Mamdani uses Oct. 7 anniversary to accuse Israel of 'genocide,' 'apartheid' Oct 8, 10 AM ET
The Western Journal Mamdani Releases Statement Remembering Oct. 7, but Spends 75 Percent of His Words Defending Hamas' Actions Oct 7, 4 PM ET
Townhall Mamdani Under Fire for His Plans on October 7 Anniversary Oct 7, 3 PM ET

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

Fox News63 min

CNN18 min

BBC News2 min

MSNOW23 s

MAMDANI DOUBLES DOWN ON HIS ISRAEL CRITICISM Fox News, 5 min
MAMDANI FACES BIPARTISAN BACKLASH FOR OCT 7 POST Fox News, 4 min
MAMDANI ON OCT. 7: "PROFOUNDLY PAINFUL FOR SO MANY NEW YORKERS" CNN, 3 min
MAMDANI DOUBLES DOWN ON OCT 7 "GENOCIDE" REMARKS Fox News, 3 min
SF MAYOR: "WE GOT SO ENTRAPPED IN OUR PROGRESSIVE VALUES" CNN, 3 min
MAMDANI'S PRO-HAMAS BASE TURNS ON HIM Fox News, 3 min
MAMDANI OCT 7 STATEMENT RIPS ISRAEL FOR "GENOCIDE" Fox News, 2 min
MAMDANI USES OCTOBER 7 ANNIVERSARY TO BASH ISRAEL Fox News, 2 min

🎙️ Shows, investigators, satire

🎙️ 📺 Hasan Piker 📨 Erick Erickson 🎙️ Bloomberg News Now

🃏 The Babylon Bee

what people online made of it

🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🗣️ names in it: Zo Mamdani Israel

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

the running story it belongs to

🧵 Oct 7 anniversary and Israel

Trauma of October 7 survivors persists
Oct 8, 6 AM ET
Israel marks third anniversary of October 7 attacks
Oct 7, 4 AM ET
NYC Mayor Mamdani criticizes Israel on October 7 anniversary, faces backlash (this story)
Oct 7, 2 PM ET

NYC Mayor Mamdani criticizes Israel on October 7 anniversary, faces backlash

📰 Spread

📡 Broadcast

📺 On TV

🎙️ Shows, investigators, satire

🧶 Retelling

🔎 Checking

🧵 Persistence

🧵 Oct 7 anniversary and Israel