🧵 Saga file #199
California death row commutations
Nov 5, 3 PM ET to Nov 14, 7 PM ET · 🔴 on the front pages now
🧵 One running story, told across days: each of its stories is on the front pages
in its own right, joined to the others because our tools judged them one case, event or investigation as it
developed. A story can be joined wrongly; the saga tracker says how they're made.
🧩 2 stories so far 📰 52 outlets carried one ⚖️ 🫏23 · 8 · 20🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 9.2 days running so far 📺 35 min of TV captions 📻 4 radio newscasts 🧶 14 people retold it online
📰 Spread
each story on the front pages, hour by hour
Nov 6 Nov 8 Nov 10 Nov 12 Nov 14 24 49 California governor commutes all death row sentences Trump criticizes Newsom's decision to commute California death row sentences
Front pages carrying each story at each hourly run, Nov 5, 3 PM to Nov 14, 7 PM ET (peak 49), stacked by story:
1 · 2
Nov 6 Nov 8 Nov 10 Nov 12 Nov 14 1. California governor commutes all …California governor commutes all death row sentences California governor commutes all death row sentences: Nov 5, 3 PM to Nov 9, 10 AM ET, 51 outlets 2. Trump criticizes Newsom's decisio…Trump criticizes Newsom's decision to commute California death row sentences Trump criticizes Newsom's decision to commute California death row sentences: Nov 14, 5 PM to Nov 14, 7 PM ET, 8 outlets 📺 TV BBC News, Nov 5, 5:24 PM ET: California governor commutes death sentences BBC News, Nov 5, 6:54 PM ET: California governor commutes death sentences BBC News, Nov 5, 8:22 PM ET: California governor commutes death sentences BBC News, Nov 5, 8:25 PM ET: state's 548 death row days could be numbered Palace aide says. inmates Fox News, Nov 5, 8:25 PM ET: NEWSOM EMPTIES DEATH ROW BBC News, Nov 5, 9:17 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state Fox News, Nov 5, 9:37 PM ET: NEWSOM COMMUTES ALL DEATH ROW SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 5, 9:37 PM ET: NEWSOM COMMUTES ALL DEATH ROW SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 5, 9:37 PM ET: RPT: INSIDERS THINK NEWSOM "PEAKED TOO EARLY" BBC News, Nov 5, 10:14 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state BBC News, Nov 5, 10:15 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state. BREAKING BBC News, Nov 5, 10:15 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state. BREAKING BBC News, Nov 5, 10:15 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state. BREAKING BBC News, Nov 5, 10:17 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state. BREAKING BBC News, Nov 5, 11:19 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state BBC News, Nov 5, 11:20 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state BBC News, Nov 5, 11:22 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state BBC News, Nov 5, 11:23 PM ET: California governor commutes all death sentences in state Fox News, Nov 5, 11:35 PM ET: CA GOV NEWSOM TO COMMUTE 548 DEATH SENTENCES BBC News, Nov 6, 12:24 AM ET: California governor commutes death sentences BBC News, Nov 6, 12:25 AM ET: California governor commutes death sentences BBC News, Nov 6, 1:25 AM ET: California governor commutes death sentences Fox News, Nov 6, 1:25 AM ET: NEWSOM EMPTIES DEATH ROW Fox News, Nov 6, 2:37 AM ET: NEWSOM COMMUTES ALL DEATH ROW SENTENCES IN CA BBC News, Nov 6, 3:45 AM ET: California governor commutes death sentences BBC News, Nov 6, 3:46 AM ET: California governor commutes death sentences Fox News, Nov 6, 4:35 AM ET: CA GOV NEWSOM TO COMMUTE 548 DEATH SENTENCES BBC News, Nov 6, 5:34 AM ET: California governor commutes death sentences Fox News, Nov 6, 6:16 AM ET: CA Gov Newsom commutes 548 death row sentences Fox News, Nov 6, 9:15 AM ET: CALIFORNIA CLEMENCY Fox News, Nov 6, 9:23 AM ET: GOV NEWSOM FACES BACKLASH OVER MASS COMMUTATIONS Fox News, Nov 6, 11:28 AM ET: CALIFORNIA CODDLING Fox News, Nov 6, 11:38 AM ET: CA SUPREME COURT MUST APPROVE RESENTENCING FOR 382 PRISONERS WITH MULTIPLE FELONY CONVICTIONS Fox News, Nov 6, 11:41 AM ET: NJ'S DISMAL DECISION Fox News, Nov 6, 5:33 PM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 6, 5:34 PM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 6, 5:39 PM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 6, 9:23 PM ET: NEWSOM SPARES ALL 548 CA DEATH ROW INMATES Fox News, Nov 6, 9:23 PM ET: NEWSOM SPARES ALL 548 CA DEATH ROW INMATES Fox News, Nov 6, 9:24 PM ET: GOV. NEWSOM SPARES 548 DEATH ROW INMATES CNN, Nov 6, 10:47 PM ET: California governor commutes all 548 death row sentences Fox News, Nov 6, 11:09 PM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 6, 11:09 PM ET: NEWSOM COMMUTES DEATH SENTENCES OF 548 INMATES Fox News, Nov 6, 11:10 PM ET: VICTIMS' FAMILIES REACT TO NEWSOM'S COMMUTATIONS Fox News, Nov 6, 11:10 PM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW SHUTDOWN SPARKS OUTRAGE Fox News, Nov 6, 11:17 PM ET: NEWSOM PLANS TO COMMUTE 548 DEATH SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 6, 11:17 PM ET: NEWSOM PLANS TO COMMUTE 548 DEATH SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 6, 11:18 PM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 6, 11:19 PM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 6, 11:19 PM ET: RPT: LARGEST MASS CLEMENCY IN U.S. HISTORY Fox News, Nov 7, 12:33 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 12:36 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 12:39 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 2:23 AM ET: NEWSOM SPARES ALL 548 CA DEATH ROW INMATES Fox News, Nov 7, 2:24 AM ET: GOV. GAVIN NEWSOM SPARES 548 DEATH ROW INMATES Fox News, Nov 7, 2:24 AM ET: GOV. GAVIN NEWSOM SPARES 548 DEATH ROW INMATES Fox News, Nov 7, 4:09 AM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 7, 4:09 AM ET: NEWSOM COMMUTES DEATH SENTENCES OF 548 INMATES Fox News, Nov 7, 4:09 AM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 7, 4:10 AM ET: VICTIMS' FAMILIES REACT TO NEWSOM'S COMMUTATIONS Fox News, Nov 7, 4:17 AM ET: NEWSOM PLANS TO COMMUTE 548 DEATH SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 7, 4:17 AM ET: NEWSOM PLANS TO COMMUTE 548 DEATH SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 7, 4:18 AM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 7, 4:19 AM ET: NEWSOM'S DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS SPARK BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 7, 4:19 AM ET: RPT: LARGEST MASS CLEMENCY IN U.S. HISTORY Fox News, Nov 7, 5:33 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 5:34 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 5:34 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 5:35 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 5:36 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 7, 5:39 AM ET: ESCAPING EXECUTION. NEWSOM COMMUTES SENTENCES OF CA DEATH ROW PRISONERS Fox News, Nov 9, 7:15 AM ET: ON THE CHOPPING BLOCK Fox News, Nov 9, 7:15 AM ET: ON THE CHOPPING BLOCK Fox News, Nov 9, 7:15 AM ET: ON THE CHOPPING BLOCK Fox News, Nov 9, 7:45 AM ET: FATHER OF SLAIN GIRL SLAMS CA DEATH ROW DECISION Fox News, Nov 9, 7:45 AM ET: FATHER OF SLAIN GIRL SLAMS CA DEATH ROW DECISION Fox News, Nov 9, 7:47 AM ET: DEATH ROW BACKLASH Fox News, Nov 9, 7:47 AM ET: NEWSOM CARRIES OUT LARGEST-EVER Fox News, Nov 9, 10:13 AM ET: NEWSOM UNDER PRESSURE FOR LENIENCY Fox News, Nov 9, 10:45 AM ET: NEWSOM MOVES TO COMMUTE ALL 548 CA DEATH SENTENCES Fox News, Nov 9, 10:45 AM ET: POLLY KLAAS' DAD REACTS TO DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS Fox News, Nov 9, 10:46 AM ET: POLLY KLAAS' DAD REACTS TO DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS Fox News, Nov 9, 10:46 AM ET: FATHER OF 12-YEAR-OLD MURDER VICTIM SPEAKS. OUT AGAINST NEWSOM'S COMMUTATION ANNOUNCEMENT Fox News, Nov 9, 10:48 AM ET: POLLY KLAAS' DAD REACTS TO DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS Fox News, Nov 9, 10:49 AM ET: POLLY KLAAS' DAD REACTS TO DEATH ROW COMMUTATIONS 📻 radio NPR News Now, Nov 6, 4:09 AM ET NPR News Now, Nov 6, 12:09 AM ET NPR News Now, Nov 5, 10:09 PM ET NPR News Now, Nov 5, 6:09 PM ET 🧶 online 🧶retold online (the day's report)
Its stories in the order of their latest news, each from when we first saw it on a front page to when we last
did; beneath, the TV captions, radio newscasts and retellings, each in the color of the story it was
about. Hover for details.
🧭 How it unfolded
each day’s news in an outlet’s own headline, in the color of its story
1 Nov 5, 4 PM ET
“Newsom commutes all 548 death sentences in California”
The Independent
1 Nov 6, 9 PM ET
“Victims' Advocates, DA Blast Newsom Death Row Commutations”
Newsmax
1 Nov 7, 11 AM ET
“Newsom’s death-row plan draws fury from DAs who are threatening legal action”
Fox News
1 Nov 9, 8 AM ET
“Gavin Newsom’s death penalty commutations prove America is in a new era”
MSNBC
2 Nov 14, 5 PM ET
“Trump rips Newsom for halting death penalty: ‘Disaster for justice‘”
Just the News
🧩 How it's been told
the stories under the saga, day by day, from our motif index: each day its most-told, wider for more tellers, colored by genre (✨ new to the saga that day)
🎭 Archetypes a kind of person
📜 Plots what happened
🪨 Beliefs a premise
🕵️ Theories what people think is behind it
🗣️ Arguments a move in an argument
⚪ left white, the smaller genres: ⚖️ Values how things ought to be
Sat Nov 7
✨ Soft on crime 1 Cruel and unusual 1
Fri Nov 6
✨ Cruel and unusual 1
🧶 Retelling
what people online made of it, story by story
Gavin Newsom is commuting all death sentences in California to life without parole.
🧶 told by 14 on “California governor commutes all death row sentences”