← back to the front page

🗞️ Story file #764

Billionaire received pardon after $50 million deal with Ex-Trump Lawyer

Oct 21, 1 PM ET to Oct 22, 1 PM ET

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

  1. Oct 21, 1 PM ETfirst on a front page: The Independent
  2. Oct 21, 5 PM ETfirst on TV: MSNOW
  3. Oct 21, 5 PM ETpeak: on 7 front pages

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

Oct 21, 6 PMOct 226 AM12 PM47left
Front pages carrying it at each hourly run, Oct 21, 1 PM to Oct 22, 1 PM ET (peak 7), by the outlets' lean: left
Oct 2112 PMOct 2212 PMNew York TimesNew York TimesNew York Times, Oct 20, 7:00 PM ET: A Billionaire Wanted a Trump Pardon. His Family Gave Alina Habba a $50 Million Deal.AlternetAlternetAlternet, Oct 20, 8:00 PM ET: Billionaire nabbed Trump clemency deal just weeks after hiring Habba for $50MHuffPostHuffPostHuffPost, Oct 20, 10:00 PM ET: Billionaire Banker Receives Pardon After Daughter Offers $50 Million Deal To Alina Habba: ReportRaw StoryRaw StoryRaw Story, Oct 21, 12:00 AM ET: Billionaire landed pardon after his family bankrolled Trump’s former lawyer: NYTMediaiteMediaiteMediaite, Oct 21, 10:00 AM ET: Political World Stunned as It’s Revealed Billionaire Scored Pardon After Alina Habba Paid $50M: ‘Send This to the New Trump Fraud Tip Line’The IndependentThe IndependentThe Independent, Oct 21, 1:00 PM ET: Venezuelan family scored a Trump pardon after giving $50M job to his ex-attorney Alina Habba: reportNew York MagazineNew York MagazineNew York Magazine, Oct 21, 5:00 PM ET: Who Is Alina Habba, Ex-Trump Lawyer Enmeshed in Scandals? The latest controversy involves a billionaire banker, a $50 million deal, and a Trump pardon.New York Magazine, Oct 21, 6:00 PM ET: Who Is Alina Habba, the Ex-Trump Lawyer in the Thick of Multiple Scandals? The latest controversy involves a billionaire banker, a $50 million deal, and a Trump pardon.SalonSalonSalon, Oct 22, 7:00 AM ET: Alina Habba’s $50 million scandal exposes MAGA pardon racket📺 TVMSNOW, 5:03 PM ET: FOR $50M JOB AS FATHER SOUGHT TRUMP PARDONMSNOW, 5:07 PM ET: FOR $50M JOB AS FATHER SOUGHT TRUMP PARDONMSNOW, 5:08 PM ET: FOR $50M JOB AS FATHER SOUGHT TRUMP PARDONMSNOW, 5:12 PM ET: FOR $50M JOB AS FATHER SOUGHT TRUMP PARDONMSNOW, 7:01 PM ET: BOMBSHELL REPORT ON TRUMP'S BILLIONAIRE PARDONMSNOW, 7:25 PM ET: NYT: BILLIONAIRE GOT PARDON AFTER FAMILY HIRED TRUMP ATTYMSNOW, 7:27 PM ET: NYT: BILLIONAIRE GOT PARDON AFTER FAMILY HIRED TRUMP ATTYMSNOW, 7:28 PM ET: NYT: BILLIONAIRE GOT PARDON AFTER FAMILY HIRED TRUMP ATTYMSNOW, 7:28 PM ET: NYT: BILLIONAIRE GOT PARDON AFTER FAMILY HIRED TRUMP ATTYCNN, 8:18 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:20 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:20 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:20 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:21 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:21 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:21 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:22 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:22 PM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 8:22 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:23 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:23 PM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 8:23 PM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 8:24 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:24 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:24 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:24 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:25 PM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 8:25 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:25 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:26 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:26 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:26 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:26 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:27 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:27 PM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 8:27 PM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 8:28 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:28 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:28 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:28 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:29 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 8:29 PM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 8:29 PM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:18 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:20 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:20 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:20 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:21 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:21 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:22 AM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 2:22 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:22 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:23 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:23 AM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 2:23 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:23 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:24 AM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 2:24 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:24 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:24 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:24 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:25 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:25 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:25 AM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 2:25 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:25 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:26 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:26 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:26 AM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 2:27 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:27 AM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 2:27 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:28 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:28 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:28 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 2:29 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 2:29 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:18 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:20 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:20 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:20 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:21 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:21 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:21 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:22 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:22 AM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 4:22 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:23 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:23 AM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 4:23 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:24 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:24 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:24 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:24 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:24 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:25 AM ET: HABBA: "I WAS NEVER PAID TO SECURE A PARDON"CNN, 4:25 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:25 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:25 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:26 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:26 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:26 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:26 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:27 AM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 4:27 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:27 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:27 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:27 AM ET: HABBA DENIES DEAL WITH BILLIONAIRE WHO GOT TRUMP PARDONCNN, 4:28 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:28 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:28 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONCNN, 4:29 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:29 AM ET: NY TIMES: BILLIONAIRE GOT TRUMP PARDON AFTER $350M DEAL WITH ALINA HABBACNN, 4:29 AM ET: HABBA: I NEVER MET WITH ANYONE AT WH OR DOJ ABOUT A PARDONMSNOW, 6:20 AM ET: BILLIONAIRE GIVES ALINA HABBA $50M DEAL AHEADMSNOW, 6:21 AM ET: BILLIONAIRE GIVES ALINA HABBA $50M DEAL AHEAD
Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not rated); a dot marks a new headline. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it (bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details.

💬 Quoted

  1. “Send This to the New Trump Fraud Tip Line”1

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

✏️ 1 outlet ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • New York Magazine (2 wordings): “Who Is Alina Habba, Ex-Trump Lawyer Enmeshed in Scandals? The latest controversy involves a billionaire banker, a $50 million deal, and a Trump pardon.” → “Who Is Alina Habba, the Ex-Trump Lawyer in the Thick of Multiple Scandals? The latest controversy involves a billionaire banker, a $50 million deal, and a Trump pardon.”
Every outlet's first headline (8), left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. 🫏 CNN 49 min
  2. 🫏 MSNOW 4 min

📻 On the radio

hourly newscasts that carried it, by programme; beside the count, how often it was the lead story, or the highest it came in the running order

📻🤷 No radio newscast matched to it.

🎙️ On the shows

podcasts, newsletters and streams that talked about it, by show; the bar is episodes; the disc is the show's lean by reputation

  1. 🫏 The Young Turks 1
  2. 🫏 MeidasTouch 1

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

🕵️ investigative reporting on it and 🃏 satire joking about it (jokes, never counted as coverage); the bar is pieces

🕵️🤷 No investigator or satirist matched to it yet.

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

  • 🧩 Pay to play 🫏 4 left shows 🐘 1 right show
    “A billionaire received a Trump pardon after his family gave Alina Habba a $50 million deal.” and 1 more
  • 🧩 Selling indulgences 🫏 4 left shows 🐘 1 right show
    “A billionaire received a Trump pardon after his family gave Alina Habba a $50 million deal.” and 1 more
  • 🧩 The family business 🫏 4 left shows 🐘 1 right show
    “A billionaire's family gave Alina Habba a $50 million deal because he wanted a Trump pardon.”

🦗 Nobody's retelling it online yet, as far as the daily reports of the last week can tell.

🗣️ Names in it

Alina HabbaDonald TrumpTrump Fraud Tip LineHabba

🔎 Checking

what the fact-checkers looked into

🧐 No fact-checker has taken it on yet.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

🌱 A story of its own so far: no saga yet.