🗞️ Story file #2133
Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park Nov 19, 11 AM ET to Nov 21, 3 AM ET
🗣️ in it: Mamdani New York City Central Park New York NYC
🔔 Notify me
👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through
TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is
part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say
how each is made.
📰 7 front pages over its life ⚖️ 🫏2 · 1 · 4🐘 left · center · right ⏱️ 1.2 days on the front pages 📈 7 front pages at once, at its peak 🧵 5 stories in its saga 🕰️ Crossed the aisle in 3 hours: first on the right (New York Post, 11:00 AM), on the left by 2:00 PM (The Guardian).
📰 read it at:
The Guardian The Independent WSJ Washington Examiner Breitbart New York Post Newsmax
📰 Spread the front pages that ran it, hour by hour
📊 by lean
🛤️ who had it
4 7 Thu Fri Sat peak: 7 front pages, Fri 8 AM Thu Nov 19, 11 AM ET: on 2 front pages (1 center, 1 right)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 12 PM ET: on 2 front pages (1 center, 1 right)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 1 PM ET: on 2 front pages (1 center, 1 right)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 2 PM ET: on 3 front pages (1 center, 1 right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 3 PM ET: on 3 front pages (1 center, 1 right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Thu Nov 19, 4 PM ET: on 4 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 5 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 6 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 7 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 8 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 9 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 10 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Thu Nov 19, 11 PM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 12 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 1 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 2 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 3 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 4 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 5 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 6 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 7 AM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 8 AM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 9 AM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 10 AM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 11 AM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 12 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 1 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 2 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 3 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 4 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 5 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 6 PM ET: on 7 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 leans right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 7 PM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 8 PM ET: on 6 front pages (1 center, 3 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages” (Newsmax) Fri Nov 20, 9 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Fri Nov 20, 10 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Fri Nov 20, 11 PM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Sat Nov 21, 12 AM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Sat Nov 21, 1 AM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Sat Nov 21, 2 AM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Sat Nov 21, 3 AM ET: on 5 front pages (1 center, 2 right, 1 left, 1 leans left)
“Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages” (The Wall Street Journal) Front pages carrying it each hour, by the outlets' lean, the side that had it first at the bottom: left leans left center leans right right.
First: New York Post and The Wall Street Journal, Thu 11:00 AM ET. Nov 19, 12 PM 6 PM Nov 20 6 AM 12 PM 6 PM Nov 21 WSJThe Wall Street Journal The Wall Street Journal, Nov 19, 11:00 AM ET: Mamdani Signs Law Banning Central Park Horse Carriages New York PostNew York Post New York Post, Nov 19, 11:00 AM ET: Mamdani officially bans horse carriages, ending century-old Central Park tradition New York Post, Nov 19, 2:00 PM ET: Union immediately sues Mamdani over horse-carriage ban as century-old Central Park industry faces doomsday The GuardianThe Guardian The Guardian, Nov 19, 2:00 PM ET: Mamdani signs bill to ban horse-drawn carriages in New York City NewsmaxNewsmax Newsmax, Nov 19, 4:00 PM ET: Mamdani Signs Ban on NYC Horse Carriages Washington ExaminerWashington Examiner Washington Examiner, Nov 19, 5:00 PM ET: Mamdani signs legislation ending 150-year tradition of horse-drawn carriages in NYC Washington Examiner, Nov 19, 5:00 PM ET: Mamdani signs legislation ending 150 years of horse-drawn carriages in NYC BreitbartBreitbart Breitbart, Nov 19, 11:00 PM ET: Mamdani Signs Ban Ending 150-Year Carriage Tradition Breitbart, Nov 20, 10:00 AM ET: Mamdani Signs Ban Ending 150-Year Horse Carriage Tradition The IndependentThe Independent The Independent, Nov 20, 8:00 AM ET: Central Park horse-drawn carriage drivers sue NYC after Mayor Zohran Mamdani signs ban Who carried it and when: each outlet in the order it picked the story up, a bar for each headline
from when we first saw it on the front page to when we last did, in the outlet's lean color (dashed: not
rated); a dot marks a new headline, and a headline swapped for a new one between our hourly looks runs on to
it. A gap means a look found the story gone from that front page. Beneath, its captions on TV, the radio newscasts that carried it
(bigger: the lead) and when people were found retelling it. Hover for details. ✏️ 3 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up) Breitbart (2 wordings): “Mamdani Signs Ban Ending 150-Year Carriage Tradition” → “Mamdani Signs Ban Ending 150-Year Horse Carriage Tradition”New York Post (2 wordings): “Mamdani officially bans horse carriages, ending century-old Central Park tradition” → “Union immediately sues Mamdani over horse-carriage ban as century-old Central Park industry faces doomsday”Washington Examiner (2 wordings): “Mamdani signs legislation ending 150-year tradition of horse-drawn carriages in NYC” → “Mamdani signs legislation ending 150 years of horse-drawn carriages in NYC”📰 Every outlet's headline 7 left to right by AllSides rating 🧵 Persistence the running story it belongs to
🧵 New York City carriage ban →
1 2 3 4 Nov 19, 11 PM ET · 📍 this story
Mayor signs law banning horse carriages in Central Park
5