← back to the front page › 🧵 California death row commutations, story 1 of 3

🗞️ Story file #1479

California governor commutes all death row sentences

Nov 5, 3 PM ET to Nov 9, 10 AM ET · 1 outlet not rated for lean

🗣️ in it: CaliforniaGavin NewsomDeath RowCalifornia Department of Corrections and

👣 How this story traveled: from the front pages that broke it, out through TV, radio and the shows, into what people retold and what fact-checkers examined, and on into the saga it is part of. Everything here is matched to the story by our tools, so a link can be wrong; the trackers' pages say how each is made.

🕰️ Both sides within the hour, by 3:01 PM Eastern.

📰 read it at: HuffPostMSNBCMother JonesRolling StoneSlateThe AtlanticThe Daily KosThe GuardianThe New RepublicAPAxiosCBS NewsCNNLos Angeles TimesMediaiteNBC NewsNew York TimesPBS NewsHourThe IndependentThe Washington PostThe WeekUSA TodayYahoo NewsBBCChicago TribuneForbesNewsweekReutersScripps NewsThe HillWSJJust the NewsThe Epoch TimesThe SunThe Washington TimesWashington ExaminerBreitbartFox NewsIJRNew York PostNewsmaxPJ MediaThe BlazeThe Daily SignalThe Daily WireThe Gateway PunditThe National DeskThe Post MillennialThe Western JournalTownhallStraight Arrow News

  1. Nov 5, 3 PM ET

    first on front pages: 14 front pages at once

  2. Nov 5, 4 PM ET

    the news that day, The Independent:

    “Newsom commutes all 548 death sentences in California”

  3. Nov 5, 5 PM ET

    first on TV: BBC News

  4. Nov 5, 6 PM ET

    first on the radio: NPR News Now

  5. Nov 6, 2 PM ET

    peak: on 46 front pages at once

  6. Nov 6, 9 PM ET

    the news that day, Newsmax:

    “Victims' Advocates, DA Blast Newsom Death Row Commutations”

  7. Nov 7, 11 AM ET

    the news that day, Fox News:

    “Newsom’s death-row plan draws fury from DAs who are threatening legal action”

  8. Nov 9, 8 AM ET

    the news that day, MSNBC:

    “Gavin Newsom’s death penalty commutations prove America is in a new era”

📰 Spread

the front pages that ran it, hour by hour

📡 Wire copy

1 outlet ran the AP, Reuters headline nearly word for word

Chicago Tribune

💬 Quoted

  1. “Progressive”1
  2. “cruel”1
  3. “in the heart”1
  4. “incompatible”1
  5. “morality”1
  6. “Incompatible With California's Values,”2

phrases its headlines put in quotation marks; the bar is how many outlets did

📌 Linked by aggregators

4 Real Clear Politics · Drudge Report · Google News · Political Wire

aggregators linking to it from their front page (they don't count as outlets covering it)

📡 How outlets rewrote the wire: AP’s headline and the 5 versions furthest from it (of 20)
  1. New York Post🕒 Nov 5, 4 PM ET🌶️ +1 spicier🌤️ +3 brighter

    California Gov. Gavin Newsom says he will dropped a bombshell move on Thursday to commute all 561 death sentences row inmates in state to life without parole California.

  2. WSJ🕒 Nov 5, 4 PM ET

    California Gov. Newsom says he will to Commute all Sentences for 548 People on Death sentences in state to life without parole Row

  3. The Washington Times🕒 Nov 5, 4 PM ET

    Gavin Newsom commutes all California Gov. Newsom says he will commute all death sentences in state to life without parole in prison

  4. Townhall🕒 Nov 6, 12 PM ET

    California Gov. Gavin Newsom says he will commute all Commutes 548 Death Sentences in state to Life without parole in Prison

  5. CBS News🕒 Nov 5, 3 PM ET🌶️ same spice🌤️ +1 brighter

    California Gov. Newsom says he will moves to commute all California death sentences in state to life without parole

The outlets whose headline changed the wire’s words the most, while keeping enough of them (three in ten or more) to be its version and not a headline of their own. Struck words are the wire’s, cut; words in pencil are the outlet’s own. 15 more changed it less.

✏️ 14 outlets ran more than one headline on it (reworded, or a follow-up)
  • BBC (2 wordings): “California governor commutes death sentences for all 548 people on death row” → “California governor commutes sentences for state's 548 death row inmates”
  • Breitbart (3 wordings): “Newsom Moves to Commute All 548 California Death Sentences to Life” → “Newsom’s Mass Commutation of Death Row Inmates Sparks Legal Battle”
  • CNN (3 wordings): “Breaking News Newsom commutes sentences of all California death row prisoners” → “Newsom commutes sentences of all California death row prisoners The move will impact the lives of 548 people in the state, which has the largest number of people under a death sentence in the US”
  • Fox News (4 wordings): “Outrage ensues as Gavin Newsom makes sweeping move on death penalty” → “California DA says Gavin Newsom's 'cruel' death row clemency stabs crime victims 'in the heart'”
  • Just the News (2 wordings): “California Dem Gov Newsom commutes all 548 death sentences in state to life in prison without parole” → “Victims' advocates slam Newsom's decision to commute death sentences”
  • Los Angeles Times (3 wordings): “Newsom moves to commute all California death sentences to life in prison without parole” → “With death sentence clemency, Newsom takes another big political risk”
  • MSNBC (3 wordings): “What Gavin Newsom’s mass commutation says about death penalty politics” → “Gavin Newsom’s death penalty commutations signify America is in a new era”
  • NBC News (3 wordings): “BREAKING: Gov. Gavin Newsom commutes all death sentences in California” → “California Gov. Gavin Newsom plans to commute all death sentences”
  • New York Post (7 wordings): “Gavin Newsom lets all of California’s 561 death row inmates escape ultimate punishment” → “Newsom reveals the moment he decided to spare all of California’s 548 death row inmates”
  • Newsmax (6 wordings): “Gov. Newsom Commuting All Death Sentences in Calif.” → “Advocates, DA Blast Newsom Death Row Plan”
  • PBS NewsHour (2 wordings): “Newsom says he will commute all 548 of California's death sentences to life without parole” → “Newsom plans to commute all of California's death sentences”
  • Straight Arrow News (2 wordings): “Gavin Newsom commutes all California death sentences” → “Newsom commutes all California death sentences; 3 other states have executions on same day”
  • The Daily Signal (2 wordings): “Newsom Moves to Spare 548 Death Row Inmates, Including Child Killers and Notorious Serial Murderers” → “Newsom’s Outrageous Death Row Commutations Offer Larger Lesson About ‘Progressive’ Governance”
  • USA Today (3 wordings): “California Gov. Gavin Newsom moves to change all state death sentences to life in prison without parole” → “Newsom wants to empty California’s death row before…”
📰 Every outlet's headline 51left to right by AllSides rating

📡 Broadcast

TV, radio, and the shows that talked about it

📺 On TV

minutes its captions were on screen, by channel; the disc is the network's lean

  1. 🐘 Fox News 28 min
  2. ⚖️ BBC News 7 min
  3. 🫏 CNN 4 s

📻 On the radio

  1. 🫏 NPR News Now 4× · best #4

🕵️ Investigated, joked about

  1. 🃏 The Babylon Bee 2
  2. 🃏 The Onion 1

🧶 Retelling

what people online made of it

🧩 How it's being told

The stories under this news, from our motif index, and who told each: the shows we follow by their lean, people online, fact-checkers. A story people tell, not a claim that it's true; claims are matched to this story by our tools, so a link can be wrong.

🧵 Persistence

the running story it belongs to

  1. 1

    Nov 5, 3 PM ET · 📍 this story

    California governor commutes all death row sentences

  2. 2
  3. 3

Not on our records yet: the shows, fact-checks.